Patriotism, nationalism, and Christian worship (a roundup)
The last few days have seen quite a number of posts on the question of whether nationalistic symbols (e.g. flags) should be displayed in worship services and/or whether Christian churches should celebrate/recognize national holidays like the 4th of July. Here are some of the more interesting posts:
- We discussed whether Christian churches should celebrate national holidays, with several commenters arguing that we should not.
- Mike Bird called for an end to displaying national flags in churches; Nick Norelli responded with a caution that use the word “idolatry” more carefully. And Joel used this as his “question of the day” today, which should generate some more interesting discussions.
- Bob Hyatt looks specifically at 4th of July celebrations and asks what a visitor would think people were worshipping in such services. In general, he thinks that such displays of patriotism lean dangerously close to idolatry.
- Matt Dabbs considers the same issue, but he draws a potentially useful distinction between patriotism and nationalism, arguing that the former is a legitimate celebration of the good that a country provides, and the latter is where the real problem lies.
- And, Michael Gorman argues that churches should stop referring to this as “Independence Sunday,” as though this actually was a day on the liturgical calendar.
I’m sure there will be other posts over the next couple of days, but this seems like more than enough for now.
Posted on July 2, 2010, in Humor, Worship and tagged church and state, Fourth of July, nationalism, patriotism, Worship. Bookmark the permalink. 4 Comments.
Marc, thanks for these links. The machinery of nationalism calls for an uncritical allegiance that tramples on the consciences of persons and wants to name as ‘secular’ that which is in origin simply ‘pagan’. Here are a few posts that may be of interest to you:
Aliens in the Church: A Reflection on ANZAC Day, National Flags and the Church as an Alternative Society
Mythologies to live – and to die – by
Stanley Hauerwas on patriotism, pacifism and just warriors
Anzac Day and the god of war
These are great links, Jason. Thanks for passing them along.
Thanks for the link and compiling these together. Always great running into new blogs.
Pingback: Civil Religion, the Church, and the Fourth of July | The Church of Jesus Christ